Best Under Eye Concealers for Mature Skin

Best under eye concealer for mature skinOne of the biggest challenges to looking as beautiful as can while we age is dealing with the skin around and under our eyes. Dark circles are no big deal when we are young and our skin is smooth and tight – resolution of dark circles is as simple as a bit of concealer, or even just extra foundation if we are really lucky. However as we age the skin around and under our eyes gets looser and the words puffy and wrinkle start to become horrifyingly meaningful. If we are not careful then makeup can accentuate rather than hide anything undesirable that our skin decides to do. Even Leonardo da Vinci would struggle to paint a nice picture when faced with a canvas like my face after a night of too many wines or too little sleep. To combat this I have become increasingly reliant on concealer – a good concealer is almost as essential to me as water and air these days. In order to find the best under eye concealer for my mature skin I have searched far and wide, and bought (and quickly thrown out!) more concealers than you would care to imagine. Without giving too much away, lets just say that I have been pursuing the holy grail of concealer for my aging skin for more than 20 years.

More Bags Than An Airport!

best under eye concealer for older skin Carole MorinWaking up with dark circles under our eyes is definitely not a good thing, and something that seems to happen more often as we get older. This is especially true when children come into the picture – they say you can tell a new mother by the size of her bags. (Both the bags under her eyes and also the handbags she carries, stuffed full of baby supplies!) However it’s not just lack of sleep that is responsible for this terrible affliction of under eye bagginess; caffeine, alcohol, dehydration and and low iron can also cause dark circles.

Can I Avoid Bags Naturally?

Well some people are lucky and don’t have to worry too much about bags and dark circles. Lucky indeed! However I personally think that most people experience them and those that don’t are lucky enough to have been born with extraordinary genetics and/or have the luxury of a lifestyle that enables them to look after themselves. To give yourself the best chance at avoiding bags and not having to use concealer under your eyes then you can do the following things to help:

  • make sure you are getting plenty of vitamins and minerals in your diet (take a multivitamin if necessary),
  • exercise regularly,
  • make an effort to get enough sleep,
  • drink lots of water and
  • in the evening avoid diuretics such as caffeine, alcohol and foods high in salt.

So there are things we can do to minimize the risk of waking up looking like a raccoon but in reality there are a host of reasons we may experience dark circles. This reddit post gives a great insight. So despite all precautions there are most likely going to be lots of times in our lives when we need to use concealer.

Your Best Weapon In The War Against Bags is Concealer

concealerUnfortunately, for some people dark circles are just something that are there and have to be dealt with. Whether it’s due to thin skin under the eyes or the factors listed above they are present and need to be dealt with. Concealer is your ally in the fight against under eye bags. It is made to be used on small discolored areas of your face to create a more even platform for foundation to be applied over. By no means is it a substitute for foundation. The general rule here is to use a concealer that’s one or two shades lighter than the color of your skin. Like all makeup less is more so do not spread it on, dabbing it works best if you are using your fingers. If you need serious coverage I would recommend using a good concealer brush to apply it – it will help you blend it and gives you more control than your fingers. I highly recommend getting yourself something like the Sephora brushes below, this made a huge difference for me. The Sephora wand is really great as all the different brush heads fit neatly into the one wand.

Check out makeup brushes on here

My Best Rated Under Eye Concealers For Mature Skin

I wrote this post in 2015 but have recently updated it to reflect what I have learned in 2016 and what I know now in 2017. When it comes to using concealer under our eyes, it is usually to hide dark circles or uneven skin tone. I still think it is best to have one product for hiding dark circles, another for uneven and discolored skin and I also like to keep a multipurpose combination all round hide it all concealer.

My Best Under Eye Concealer for Hiding Dark Circles

The Benefit Cosmetics Boi-ing Industrial Strength Full Coverage Concealer would have to be the best performing concealer I’ve ever used when it comes to covering dark circles. If you’ve missed a LOT of sleep then this could be your savior. It provides fantastic coverage and blends really well, even when you wake up looking like a raccoon and have to really pile it on. Well the best thing about this is that you don’t actually have to pile it on because it covers so well. The skin under my eyes is not as tight as it once was so I try to minimize the amount of product used here and the erase paste covers well without a thick application which suits me perfectly.

Check prices on

My Best Under Eye Concealer for Uneven and Discolored Skin

When celebrities branch out with products outside of their usual area of expertise the results are often terrible. In this case though, Fashion guru Giorgio Armani has really excelled with the GIORGIO ARMANI POWER FABRIC HIGH COVERAGE STRETCHABLE CONCEALER 5.5. He has put out quite a lot of beauty products including different kinds of makeup and from my experience some have been good and others have been garbage. This concealer is great though – it’s amazing for pigmentation, freckles, spots, blemishes etc. It can disguise undesired marks of almost any color on my face and is a must for any makeup bag.

Check prices on

My Best Combination Under Eye Concealer

For an all round emergency concealer to keep in your purse, you can’t go past Physicians Formula Concealer Twins Cream Concealers. It comes as a neat little two in one package with a light fleshy color on one end and a green on the other. It’s not a high end concealer but it’s very good for the price and is certainly good enough to get you out of trouble. It has a really nice creamy consistency and a super smooth fine finish. The green hides any red blotchiness so well and I just find it so handy to have both colors in the one stick – Lord knows I have enough junk in my bag already!

Check prices on

Dark Circles And Puffiness?

If you have both dark bags and puffiness under your eyes then a concealer can only help you so much. You will want to use a different kind of product, I have written about what I think the best ones are in this article: how to reduce under eye puffiness.

Video – How to hide dark undereye circles

Follow Facebooktwitter Share Facebooktwitterredditpinterestmail


  1. Maine

    Hello. I was going to pass your site, I don’t think concealer would be my thing, but I remembered my wife was horrified by the black circles under her eyes and boy did I hear about it, and what a wealth of information you had in your site, the infor was awsome, to be difinitely shared with my lovely wife 🙂

    1. Mary (Post author)

      Haha thanks Maine. Good luck with your lovely wife!

  2. Sarah

    I’m glad that Physcian’s Formula is on here. They’re the most expensive makeup that I’ll let myself buy. I often get my foundation and powders from them and keep the cheap stuff for things like eyeliner. I’ve never even ventured out to find the more expensive things because it’s really just too much. do you have Physician’s Formula products reviewed elsewhere on your site?

    1. Mary (Post author)

      Hi Sarah,

      I agree – foundation and concealer are important and if you are going to skimp on anything it shouldn’t be them! My site is still in its infancy but as I get more time I will be adding reviews of many products including Physician’s Formula. Be sure to check back!

  3. Lucinda Freestone

    Dear Mary

    Useful article on concealers.

    I have mature skin now and agree that some days the dark circles are more prominent than others. I don’t go out as much as I used to as I am now working from home but, when I do, I do use concealer and I find that my makeup looks so much better.

    I will definitely take the products that you advertise into account.

    1. Mary (Post author)

      Thanks Lucinda I’m glad you enjoyed it.

  4. john waldie

    Hi there nice site! I am a man and as you are speaking of made up this page really doesn’t apply to me. Does not mean I did not read and I must say you really know what you’re doing and you put it out there very easily to comprehend and I can see you being a big help to your customers or visitors so keep up the excellent work!

    1. Mary (Post author)

      Thanks John, you never know when this info might come in handy for your wife/girlfriend/sister/mother etc!

  5. Mianka

    You totally saved me some money today!
    I also have a bag full of everything that does not do the job!
    I have seen this dark circle thing go through my whole Family – haha – at least there is something like concealer. I will try your advice.
    Do you think that a concealer like this will cover dark scars?

    1. Mary (Post author)

      Hi Mianka, you’re wlecome! If the scar is smooth and just a dark color concealer will help however if the scar is raised or sunken then it will be harder to hide. Good luck!

  6. renan

    Hi Mary
    While looking for a best under eye concealer for mature skin I found your post as one that best advice I could get, anyway I have a question that is very important since all refer to or suggest to only for skin women, perhaps you believe that the same treatment can be effective for men? I think there should be no difference you believe? Thank you very much for sharing your experience in skin care, my wife adore your comments.

    1. Mary (Post author)

      Hi Renan, you are absolutely right – the same treatments for women can be used on men. I think the main difference in men’s and women’s products is the packaging and marketing.

  7. shelby

    I really enjoyed your article. I am only 22 but I have had really bad dark circles since I can remember. I am wondering if there is any kind of lightener I could put on under my eyes that would be beneficial or is it better to just stick with concealer? Also what concealer would you recommend for this problem?

    1. Mary (Post author)

      Hi Shelby, at 22 I don’t think you have anything to worry about! I am wary of lightening products and personally think that you are best off sticking with a good concealer. In my opinion Erase Paste by Benefit Cosmetics would be best for you. Good luck!

  8. DrSarahBrewer

    I’ve not heard of Physician’s Formula – guess it must be a US brand? I’ve used YSL Touche Eclat with some success, but as a medical nutritionist I know diet can really help as among the causes of dark circles (heredity, tiredness and fatigue, hormonal imbalances, kidney problems, dry skin, allergies/dermatitis, dehydration) they can be due to nutritional deficiencies especially of vitamins A, C, K, E and iron-deficiency anaemia. Thanks.

    1. Mary (Post author)

      Great information, thank you!


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.